When someone passes away, the question of who inherits their assets becomes crucial. 

In Indonesia, this process is governed by a mix of legal systems, including the Civil Code (Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Perdata, or KUHPer) and Islamic law, as outlined in the Compilation of Islamic Law (Kompilasi Hukum Islam, or KHI). While intestacy, where someone dies without a will, has its own rules for distributing estates, the power of a last will (testament) often takes precedence. 

Let’s explore how the last will has become a game-changer in estate distribution in Indonesia.

The Basics of Intestacy in Indonesia

Intestacy occurs when someone dies without leaving a valid will. In such cases, their estate is distributed according to the default rules set by law. In Indonesia, the rules differ based on the deceased’s religion and whether they are subject to the Civil Code or Islamic law.

Under the Civil Code, intestacy follows a tiered system of heirs. The first priority goes to the spouse and children, who share the estate equally. If there are no children, the estate passes to the parents and siblings. If none of these relatives exist, the estate moves further down the family tree, eventually going to the state if no heirs are found.

For Muslims, the KHI applies, and the estate is distributed based on Islamic inheritance law (faraid). This system divides the estate into fixed shares for specific heirs, such as children, spouses, parents, and siblings. Sons typically receive double the share of daughters, reflecting traditional Islamic principles.

While these rules provide a clear framework, they may not always align with the deceased’s wishes. This is where the last will comes into play.

The Power of the Last Will

A last will allows you to decide who gets what after you’re gone. It’s a legal document that overrides intestacy rules, as long as it complies with the law. In Indonesia, the Civil Code and KHI both recognize the validity of wills, but they impose certain limitations.

Under the Civil Code, you can leave your assets to anyone, but there’s a catch: you must respect the “legitime portie” (reserved portion). This means that certain heirs, like your children and spouse, are entitled to a minimum share of your estate. You can only freely dispose of the portion that exceeds this reserved share.

For Muslims, the KHI allows you to distribute up to one-third of your estate through a will. The remaining two-thirds must follow Islamic inheritance rules. However, if all heirs agree, the will can override these restrictions, giving you more flexibility.

By creating a will, you can ensure that your assets go to the people or causes you care about most, rather than being distributed according to rigid legal formulas. This ability to personalize your estate plan is one reason why the last will has gained prominence over intestacy.

Why Intestacy Falls Short

Intestacy rules are designed to provide a fair and predictable system for distributing estates, but they have limitations. First, they don’t account for personal relationships or unique family dynamics. For example, if you have a close friend or a non-biological child you want to include, intestacy won’t allow it. Similarly, if you want to leave more to one child due to special circumstances, intestacy rules won’t accommodate this.

Second, intestacy can lead to disputes among heirs. When the law dictates who gets what, it may not align with everyone’s expectations, causing tension and even legal battles. A well-drafted will can help prevent such conflicts by clearly stating your intentions.

Finally, intestacy doesn’t allow for charitable giving or other specific wishes. If you want to leave part of your estate to a charity, a religious institution, or a community project, you need a will to make it happen.

Legal Grounds Supporting the Last Will

Both the Civil Code and KHI provide a solid legal foundation for the use of wills in Indonesia. Let’s take a closer look at the key provisions.

Civil Code

Articles 875 to 940 of the Civil Code govern wills in Indonesia. These articles outline the requirements for making a valid will, including the need for it to be in writing and signed by the testator (the person making the will). They also specify the types of wills recognized under the law, such as testamentary wills and holographic wills, handwritten by the testator.

The Civil Code also emphasizes the importance of the legitime portie, ensuring that certain heirs cannot be completely disinherited. This balance between respecting the testator’s wishes and protecting the rights of heirs is a hallmark of the Civil Code’s approach to wills.

Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI)

For Muslims, the KHI provides additional guidance on wills. Article 195 of the KHI states that a will is valid if it does not exceed one-third of the estate, unless all heirs consent to a larger portion. Article 194 emphasizes that a will must be made voluntarily and cannot harm the rights of heirs.

The KHI also recognizes the concept of “hibah” (gifts), which can be used alongside a will to distribute assets during the testator’s lifetime. This flexibility allows Muslims to plan their estates in a way that aligns with both their personal wishes and religious principles.

Real-Life Impacts of the Last Will

The growing use of wills in Indonesia has had a significant impact on estate distribution. By allowing individuals to bypass intestacy rules, wills have empowered people to take control of their legacies. Here are a few examples:

1. Blended Families.  In cases where someone has children from multiple marriages, a will can ensure that all children are treated fairly, even if they don’t fall under the same legal framework.
2. Charitable Giving. Many Indonesians use wills to support causes they care about, such as education, healthcare, or religious institutions. This wouldn’t be possible under intestacy rules.
3. Avoiding Disputes. By clearly stating their intentions, testators can reduce the likelihood of disputes among heirs, preserving family harmony.
4. Supporting Non-Heirs. Wills allow individuals to leave assets to people who aren’t recognized as heirs under the law, such as friends, caregivers, or distant relatives.

Challenges and Considerations

While the last will offers many advantages, it’s not without challenges. Drafting a will requires careful planning and legal expertise to ensure it complies with the law. Any mistakes or ambiguities can lead to disputes or even invalidate the will.

Additionally, cultural factors can influence how wills are perceived. In some communities, there’s a strong expectation to follow traditional inheritance practices, which can make it difficult for individuals to assert their wishes through a will.

Finally, the legitime portie and the one-third rule under the KHI can limit the testator’s freedom, especially in cases where they want to leave most of their estate to a single beneficiary or a non-heir.

Conclusion

You and I both know that planning for the future is essential, especially when it comes to our loved ones. In Indonesia, the last will has emerged as a powerful tool for shaping your legacy and ensuring your wishes are respected. By allowing you to bypass the rigid rules of intestacy, a will gives you the freedom to distribute your assets in a way that reflects your values and priorities.

Whether you’re governed by the Civil Code or the KHI, the legal framework supports your right to make a will, as long as you respect certain limitations. By taking the time to draft a clear and legally compliant will, you can avoid the pitfalls of intestacy and leave behind a legacy that truly represents who you are.

My name is Asep Wijaya, writing for Wijaya & Co. We orchestrate to assist you navigate. Thank you for reading my posts.

***

Our thanks to Asep Wijaya of Wijaya & Co for sharing this article.